Petsmart has been my go-to pet store for what feels like an eternity. The kitty that I grew up with got many toy, treat and meal from this location in the years before Amazon and online shopping.
We still go here for all of our pets, primarily for food and the clearance toys and treats. The markup is otherwise high on new products.
Blue Buffalo Wilderness, however, is within a dollar or two in price as compared to online retailers.
Plus the staff is always friendly to us and our hound dog! One lady always comes to look for her when we are in the store to say "hi!"