Our first visit to Montana Mikes was early June 2010. We were pleasantly surprised by the amount of food you get for the price. I ordered beef tips (which were excellent), my father ordered the sirloin steak which he said he was happy with, and my mom ordered the salmon, which she said was excellent. With our salads, they brought us three buns with yummy cinnamon butter; the first batch was better than the second, I think the second batch was in the oven about 2 minutes too long!
We returned to Montana Mike's this past weekend to celebrate Fathers Day. Again, we had a pretty good experience. The only negative I can say was that (yes - it was busy and we expected to wait) we ended up waiting over 25 minutes, and in the end were seated at bar tables that they claim they don't like to seat people at unless they ask first - personally, they could have asked 15 minutes earlier and we still would have said no problem sitting there.
Overall both of our experiences have been just fine (waiters and waitresses have been pleasant and attentive; food good and what we expected) and I would say we will return again so long as it continues.