Ive eaten here a couple of times now (all for lunch) and the best I can come up with is "meh". It's sad, really, because the place could be so much better, but it just isn't.
In mist recently on Thursday and sat outside at the deck, which was surprisingly nice. I didn't know the person I was meeting for lunch, and the confused wait staff kept bringing people by my table to see if they were the person I was meeting - didn't quite connect with the fact that there should be a name associated with a table, not just "guy meeting someone".
I had the pickerel special, and it was pretty soggy and bland. Bread service was fine, and the highlight was the biscotti that they brought with coffee after.
I'm sure that lunch is a really hard meal to pull off, but it shouldn't be this hard.