I think I found my favorite place in Madison! This bar has it all - it's charming, a little vintage, and serves killer drinks. We tried quite a few of the drinks and not one disappointed us! I ordered the spiked cider for myself and it was like drinking apple pie. I could drink it All. Day. Long. We also tried the Nitro Amaretto Sour and it would make a great dessert! The perfect amount of sweetness, and almond-y goodness. The Dark and Stormy has on-site homemade ginger beer that is so fresh and has a little bite to it. My least favorite drink was the This is a Spicy Drink. It was really, a spicy drink. It starts off cool and refreshing, then there's a little kick at the end. I said this was my least favorite, but that's only because I'm kind of a wimp and don't like spicy things. It was still a great drink, just not up my alley.
Our service was great. We were there on a Sunday night, and the only patrons in there, but the bartender was very knowledgeable. She gave us great advice, and told us about a local distillery that makes one of the ciders they have on tap.
Great place. Cannot wait to go back!