I have been to Mason's twice now and both times I have not been impressed. I went a second time because I thought I was crazy for not loving them like so many people do...
I had Pumpkin Pie, which tasted okay as a sample and my boyfriend had Butter Pecan. They both lacked the creamy texture that you would expect from ice cream and tasted more like freezer/ice and fell apart as we ate it.
The ice creams taste like they barely have any of the main ingredient in them, seriously lacking flavor. It was a sad day for our tastebuds and my waistline because I finished eating it since I paid for it and didn't even enjoy it.
On the bright side, they play good music, have cool decor and a nice vibe, and color changing spoons.
I'll stick to Mitchell's and Sweet Moses.