Great atmosphere. Meat&Potatoes has the best and the most interesting cocktails in town (and they are consistent at that!). The food was superb - she had the agnoletti, and I the pappardelle (bolognese), which was much improved from the first them I had it.
On the downside, their facilities (washrooms shared with the cabaret club next door) are below par and simply do not go with the rest of this place. The solution they used to have was much better. So, one star less.