I've been to Gary's Tied House a few times now - 4 I think, maybe 5. I really like this place. Now I haven't sat at the bar for a game, or gone out on the patio for drinks. My experience has been mainly coming here for dining only.
Each time I was here I think I've tried something different. I've been happy every time. The prices are a touch high, but the portions are good and the quality too - and those are just as if not more important.
When I was there last Sunday, I tried the Beef Brisket Grinder sandwich with chips. Beef Brisket with Scrambled eggs and chips and cheese sauce on a French Roll. Sounded too good to pass up. It really was quite awesome. My wife had the Pacific Rim Salad. She liked it a lot, although it was a bit spicy - but she knew that from the menu description. I can't recall the other menu items I've tried before, besides knowing that I've tried a burger. All have been quite well prepared and above your average pub food. Compliments have been unusual including this odd sauce that comes with their chips - super yummy but i have no idea what it is.
A few times we have come on a Friday or a weekend, and its been a bit busy. But they are doing things right so I guess that to be expected. Not sure why I'm not giving them 5 stars - I guess I've only had a few of their beers and haven't tried the patio or anything. We'll give a few more tries and see if they can earn the fifth one. : )