I've seen some mixed reviews for Andreoli's. Let me set you straight: this is an authentic, family-owned place. If you come somewhat regularly (you should!), you will recognize the same people each time. Some of the younger employees seem to have a little bit of an attitude, but most of the staff are very attentive and authentic and truly want you to have a great experience.
There is brick-oven pizza on Wednesdays and Saturdays. I've had this on two separate occasions and had quite different experiences. The first time it was great, the second time the crust was a bit soggy. I think they were simply busy and didn't leave it in long enough.
What I keep coming back for are the sandwiches. They are amazing and also have great vegetarian options. I highly recommend the eggplant sandwich, even if you typically eat meat. Its great! The calamari (both the friend and grilled) are also great if you eat fish!
They have several different beer and bottles of wine you can purchase, or you can choose a glass of the house wine. Come early if you don't want to wait. Otherwise, come for lunch! Always order coffee and dessert -its definitely worth it!