I'm a serial barbershop hopper. I've bounced around all over the city looking for the perfect cut and let me tell you, it probably doesn't exist. It might just be that my head is shaped funny and curly hair doesn't compliment the oblong surface, but I just haven't found the right place yet.
Garrison's came very close though. I was very happy with my cut, and my barber and I chatted about movies for a while which was nice. I went during a week day so it was empty and service was quick. The only thing preventing me from returning was the price. It was pretty expensive. I ended up paying $45 after tax and tip. Maybe I'm just used to the standard $25 per cut, but if I've ever paid more I usually get a beard trim or something.
So overall: great cut, great service, slightly expensive, probably worth it.