If my husband was on Yelp, he'd give this place 5 stars. He loves the Colony. I'd give it 3. So, let's be generous and say 4 for the both of us. This is a homey place and has a nice patio for good weather. The food has been inconsistent for me - I've had amazing things (their wings are great), some satisfying things (lobster mac and cheese) and some not great things (some sub-par sandwiches and weak fries). I've never had an issue with the service. We worked with the late owner to rent out their back room for a party and he was a pleasure to work with and everyone enjoyed themselves.
I'm glad that they stayed open after the tragic death of the owner and I see that they're really trying to continue on like he would have wanted.