We weren't expecting much based on reviews but we were pleasantly surprised. We made reservations for 5:30, but didn't actually need them. I even checked on our way out and we wouldn't have needed them at 6:30 either.
As for the food, we went on a Friday so of course we had the fish fry. My husband had the perch with scalloped potatoes and I had the perch with a baked potato. When I go back I'll choose the scalloped potatoes, they were creamy and delicious - not that there was anything wrong with the baked potato. The fish was cooked thorough and was very good. The thing to note is the portion of the perch. We took home an entire portion! As many have mentioned the bread and cinnamon butter is a nice welcoming touch to dinner.
We finished dinner off with a brownie and ice cream. I was expecting a scoop of vanilla on a brownie square but instead had moose track ice cream on top of a cakey warm brownie with whipped cream, caramel and chocolate sauce. We couldn't finish it!
All in all, this is a warm and friendly supper club. The servers were very friendly and it never felt forced. Our water was constantly filled and we never felt like we had to wait for anything.