This place is a mixed bag for me. It's not bad, but there's nothing about it that screamed "make me your favorite" either. It's an upscale place for sure and it appears to cater to the theater crowd. The thing with theater restaurants is that if you go at 6, it's packed. If you go at 8, it's dead. Really dead and eerily quiet because their music wasn't working. We were the only people there, which was sort of awkward since it felt like the entire staff could hear everything we said all night.
What pulled up the star rating was the Lobster Mac-N-Cheese. Completely worth the $16! Creamy and flavorful with a hint of herbs (which also make it look extra good). Big chunks of lobster and bread crumbs on the top rounded it out nicely.
Overall, I just didn't get a warm and fuzzy feeling from this place, despite the good food. I would describe it more as stuffy and uppity than warm and inviting. I might try it again in the dining room since the food was good, but then again, maybe not.