Sorry folks, not a fan.
Segredo is way out of place in a college town like Madison. If it was anywhere else, it could probably get away with the $10+ cover and the $5 coat check. Unfortunately, it feels like Segredo tries really hard to be something that it is not, instead of just catering to the young professionals and college students in the area.
I was there for the Cataracs concert, and I was extremely turned off by the unfriendly staff. Understandably, it was a busy night, but I expected a certain standard of hospitality that the Segredo staff just did not exhibit.
One thing I did appreciate was the quick email responses to an inquiry of a jacket I'd left behind. I was able to pick it up the next afternoon while they were cleaning for the night.