Came here a while back and it didn't really meet my expectation despite all the rave reviews. You see a lot of other reviews about this restaurant saying that what they got left them still hungry which is unfortunately true. Got the Baja & Polo Con Mole tacos as our mains and chips and guac for the appetizer. Expect to pay around $15 for three tacos & $12 for chips/guac (pretty steep) and have them leaving you to want more. Not exactly for the taste (they're good) but you're still hungry. They definitely need to step up on the portion sizes to justify the means of their pricing.
The restaurant has a nice vibe and everyone is in a good mood. The service is slow and there are numerous other great Mexican restaurants out there in Toronto that makes this one skippable. Come here for the vibe & great talks with friends but other than that, El Catrin doesn't live up to the hype.