I've never had anything bad here! This time I ordered the Pimento Cheese & Tomato Grilled Panini (White and yellow cheddar with roasted red peppers topped with tomato) on sourdough (you can pick your own bread!). It was perfect. The boyfriend similarly ordered the grilled cheese which was basically a simplified version of mine (Cheddar, provolone and tomato). I tried his too and it was also really good! My friends ordered the Fig & Brie Panini and the Avocado Melt and both looked amazing. I've had the Avocado Melt before and enjoyed it very much. Fig & Brie is next on the list!
The pastries are also excellent! Get a cheddar biscuit as a side. You won't regret it.
The atmosphere here is also very chill. Order at the counter and then find open seating. There are some outdoor tables available and then the cafe has bar seats along their windows as well as tables for parties of various sizes. That being said, it's a small place, so don't come with more than like 6 people and expect to find a place to sit.
Saturdays are less busy than Sundays.