My wife and I and a few of our closest friends ate at Cartwright's a few months ago and the meal was outstanding. My wife enjoyed it so much that she requested to go back on her birthday with our best friends only to find out that the menu and decor has changed, unfortunately not for the best. The only consistency are the relatively high prices ($39 for a little Elk, Buffalo and Beef).
The food was underwhelming if not forgettable. The Caesar salad had so many random Southwestern infused ingredients that I am not sure it is a Caesar salad. For the price point there are several other better options. Needless to say we were disappointed and will not be going back.