I'm that guy who is always leery of mechanics and their suspicious repair recommendations, but I fully trust Christian Family Automotive. Their prices are fair compared to other independent mechanics, and so far, they have done an excellent job. What sets them apart, though, is that they always take the time to fully explain exactly what service they performed on your vehicle.
Pro tip: ask them about their membership club (cannot remember what it's called). You prepay for several oil changes, tire rotations, and other services, but it saves you quite a bit over the long run.