Food is amazing (I always order a large platter with fatty meat). Why only four stars? Service is hit-or-miss.I once brought an American friend here and the service was so bad it really left a bad taste in his mouth... It's not the kind of impression you want to leave tourists visiting Montreal.
Also, do not order smoked turkey. In the spirit of Thanksgiving, we once ordered a small platter of smoked turkey. It was literally sliced cold cuts of turkey meat, the type you would expect to find in the deli section of your local grocery store.