Motivated by a Groupon and the fact that this place is close to my house, I tried Papa Kelsey's last night. Considering the location which is a half dead strip mall, I wasn't expecting much. What a surprise! First of all, the place is really BIG! They have lots of tables and everything looked notably squeaky clean! They have ample bench seating for people waiting for takeout orders!
They have one style of crust and it is pretty close to being labelled as thin, which is great with me. I ordered the garlic pizza (white, olive oil) with fresh tomato slices. It was so flavorful and generously cheesy and the tomatoes gave it such a bright fresh zing.
I also ordered the meatball sub. The bread was soft and fresh, the meatballs were tender and addicting! Again, generously cheesy.
I'll be back to try more things!