"Yay! I'm a fan" is a pretty spot on description of iPic. I'm a fan. I can't be a regular because it's so dang expensive but I could never forget about it because the two times I've been there I've had a great time. The food is pretty good but since you're in an expensive movie theater, don't expect the food to be cheap.
I'm still not sure how I feel about having servers during a movie, it's a bit of a nuisance so I would suggest that you don't go see a movie you REALLY want to see because it's likely to be interrupted every now and then.
Overall it's an incredible movie-going experience because there isn't anything like it. iPic is one of a kid and if I could see movies there for the rest of my life at the same price as other theaters I wouldn't hesitate on that opportunity.