Closer to a 4.5/5. Here's a breakdown:
-Homemade guac and chips: Excellent, love that you can vary the heat-level.
-Corn on the cob: Heavenly, slathered with cheese, onions, and lime juice.
-Chicken wings: Not too greasy, good amount of spice.
-Lobster tacos: Amazing. Lobster was soft and succulent. The guac that came with it also tasted incredibly fresh.
-Baja fish tacos (battered): I'd say overall they were tasty and fresh, but nothing out of this world. I like how they didn't over-batter the fish.
-Dave's margarita. Maybe a little too much ice, but still went down smoothly.
The space is a bit cramped, so it's probaly not the best option for an intimate one-on-one. Music can be a bit loud. On the plus side, our server was friendly and very attentive. And considering all the food we ordered, the bill at the end of the night was also pretty reasonable.