Love it. Tasty selection of Scottish and other craft beers and an array of whiskeys and scotch. The lighting is very dim (a tad too dim?) but this is certainly preferable to overly bright. They accommodated our reservation for 6 at the very last minute and managed to save us a table on a busy Thursday night. Also a comfortable place to grab a drink at the bar solo.
I always though that haggis was "gross" but its actually quite delightful. Sort of like a meatloaf / shepherd's pie but with lamb, and better! The fish & chips are what you would expect: deep fried and filling.Our Scottish server was very Scottish - accent and all. She was patient with the late arrival of part of our group and invited us back for a whiskey event the following week. She was friendly and quite funny.
I will definitely return. Caledonian is ALMOST a 5-star but loses a point for a somewhat aggressive up-selling of additional drinks. Apart from that minor mishap, I am absolutely delighted and pleasantly surprised with The Caledonian.