Saw The Gilbert House on a local "Check Please" PBS weekly restaurant review series where they share dining-out experiences on their favorite Arizona restaurants! When all three of them like a restaurant, we add it to our must try list. Very glad to report that The Gilbert House is a "keeper" and we are already looking forward to another visit. Next time we do breakfast. Today, we planned a late lunch. After watching "Check Please" we knew we wanted to try the Buffalo Burger, the Fruited Spinach Salad and the Green Chili Stew. The stew was perfect, heavy with flavor, not to spicy and it didn't last very long. The Fruited Salad was perfect! The fruit fresh and sweet, the spinach cold and crunchy, the candied nuts and the wonderful dressing was the best salad we have had in a long long time. The Buffalo Burger was ever bit as good as the reviewers said it would be. Be sure and tell them rare or medium rare (comes with grilled onions and you can order lots of extras). We really enjoyed the owners visits and decided to get a couple take home pie slices. This is going to be at the top of list for out of town visitors. Don't expect fast food service times. You are going to really enjoy the freshness of the prepared to order food.