I'm also another Yelper that's confused to why there are so many negative reviews on this page. I've been coming here with family for years, and had gatherings here in the past as well. This is my go-to restaurant in Danforth and I have never been disappointed before.
There's a wide variety of food and drink selections, the atmosphere is beautiful, and the staff are so friendly and helpful.
If you're looking for appetizers definitely try the fried calamari and the mussels! The calamari makes you want to lick your fingers after you're done and the mussels don't have that fishy taste/smell that you get at other restaurants.
My personal favourite is the lamb souvlaki! The meat is a bit too chewy, but the pieces are quite large so I always find myself taking some home afterwards because I can't finish my food at the restaurant. I'm a big fan of their greek salad too.
If you feel discouraged by the other reviews, I say still give Pappas a chance! Since it's two floors it's a great place for parties, and even for quiet dates.
I hope Pappas is here for years to come!