Okay folks...I don't know about this place being 4 stars? It is definitely good food but I can't say I experienced anything that was out of the ball park excellent nor did I see anything on the limited menu that looked like it had the possibility of being fantastic.
So I came here with the wife on a Sunday night. I thought the decor was exactly what I expected but the menu was not very complex which I'm totally cool with. The menu had a total of 7 entrees which at least 3 of them where pasta dishes. I had the bolognese which yes, was good, didn't feel that with the included salad was worth $17. The sausage in the sauce was nice and spicy. My wife had the eggplant caprese which I also tried and that was not a well executed dish and to the say the least was bland.
I don't think I will come back to this place just because I don't know what is going to be on the menu for the day and if it will be cooked to perfection. From the other reviews I have read it seems like this place is suffering from consistently being inconsistent.
My advice to someone else is go give it a try and let me know how it was...