The Old Fashioned is one of those places I always forget about and then think "man, I need to come here more often" every time I go back. I can't recall having been disappointed in anything I have eaten here. The brunch specials are top notch.
Now, that being said, there are two things people need to do when they come here.
1. Eat the cheese curds.
2. Get an old fashioned (Brandy, Sweet..always)
Everyone else has already said, so just do it. I don't think you will regret it, and more than likely you will thank all of us for the awful stomach ache you have from eating way too many curds and drinking that 3rd old fashioned you probably didn't need.