I love Indian food. I love cooking it and I love eating it. Sitara is amazing when I want that feel good Indian meal without all the dishes. They have a huge menu and the flavors are amazing. I see some poor service complaints, but every time I've been the service has been wonderful. The only service issue worth complaining about is waiting to get a table when it's their dinner rush. It's almost always half full. Yea the water is served luke warm, but ice is kind of an American thing. I'd give them an extra star just for pure authenticity! And I'm sure if you asked for a cup of ice they'd oblige. Oh, did I mention how clean it is in the dinning area? (I can't speak for the bathrooms, never used them)
But back to the food... Can we say yum?! Nothing here is bland. But if you're afraid of Indian food because it's too spicy, I've never had a dish that I couldn't handle. If you ask for extra spice though, it'll knock your socks off.
Dishes I'd recommend to anyone:
Mutter paneer - it comes out a bright red color that looks like it would melt your face off, but don't be afraid! It's not spicy at all. But damn is it good. Chicken and vegetable korma - classic go to for me. Very creamy and tons of veggies.
Chicken tikka - always a classic standby if you're just scoping the establishment out.
The naan and specialty naans are also worth checking out. And make sure to ask for the mint chutney as a condiment. You can add it to your dish for a little more kick or dip your naan in it.
Did I mention I love Sitara?