Dewey's is my favorite place to get pizza in Cleveland. The crust has just the right amount of crispness, and the toppings are always very fresh. The combinations they have all are pretty good. The bbq chicken is one of my favorites. They also have really good calzones. They basically fold half of a medium size pizza and stuff it full of sauce, 2 cheeses, and 3 toppings of your choice (either premium or regular, which makes it a good deal). The calzones themselves are under $10, and I usually have to take half home because it's so big. As for the actual toppings, there's a wide selection to choose from.
I also like their salads. Very fresh and tasty.