I don't know what it is about this place that has people constantly seeing it, being intrigued, but not stopping in. I was exactly the same.
The old-school sign, the pinball machine, the sparse interior that can be seen through huge glass windows, and the obvious feeling that this place has been a part of this iconic Pittsburgh neighborhood for ages.
The sandwiches are big and made right in front of you and the people are so incredibly welcoming it can start to feel like a second home!