Andy is a card. Any New Yorker willing to tout the superiority of his gelato to our group via a song is a man worthy of respect. And yes, the gelato is delicious. Spumoni = perfect. Seriously.
I hope LPC gets around to roasting their own gyro meat again. The lamb they've been buying hasn't been the same quality, and you can taste the difference. However, if enough of us ask, maybe he'll start roasting in-house again! It's worth it, trust me.
This is a great lunchtime spot, and yes, the owner (Andy) is polarizing. But if you've an open mind and a discriminating sandwich palate (as I do), then you really can't go wrong here. Oh, and now they're serving beer & wine - before it was BYOB with a corkage.
Try the orzo!