I have no idea how Made by Marcus can constantly be lined up down the block but not this place. I also have no idea how the same people who gave Made by Marcus five stars and then less for Scrollio because of "the wait" can possibly be serious. There is almost never a line-up at Scrollio and yeah, there's a wait - but they are literally MAKING YOUR ICE CREAM FOR YOU. And all for basically the same price as a Dairy Queen blizzard - with one of their creations being more than enough for two people to share. I ordered a scoop of ice cream at Made by Marcus on a slow night and ended up waiting 20 minutes for it. I sure as heck wasn't watching it being made so I'm not entirely sure what took so long there.
In addition to watching your ice cream being made (which is fascinating!) Scrollio is like a small town ice cream shop. The employees chat with everyone, and it's got a great laid back vibe. The air conditioning in the shop is lovely if you want a cool down with your ice cream from the hot summer sun, or they have a lovely little shady area out front complete with a swinging bench.
And finally, the ice cream itself is FANTASTIC. There's only vanilla and chocolate available but they roll your favourite toppings right into it. It usually takes about 10 minutes or so, so if you're in a hurry, move along. But if you want to actually take a break and enjoy fresh made ice cream, then I'd strongly suggest leaving the Made by Marcus line-up and taking a jaunt down the block to Scrollio.