From my perspective, this place is as good as it gets. No menu here, although I'm sure they already know based on available ingredients what will be prepared for the evening. Instead, you select what you don't or can't eat from a list and then are surprised by what comes out. While this is somewhat foreign to a dining experience, we had fun with it, learning in the process that 2 ingredients we thought we didn't like were actually delicious given the preparation.
We both selected 5 courses (you select from 4-7 I believe) and it was plenty of food. Servings are small but almost all of ours were delicious. I had 2 fish dishes and enjoyed both, but the highlight was a deconstructed key lime pie for dessert.
I'm not going to go on about ingredients in every dish and pretend to be the food critic I am not; rather, if you want a nice atmosphere, great service and outstanding food based on what you like and how you like things prepared, this place delivers.