I stopped by here a couple of Tuesdays ago for lunch with my father and goddaughter. Don's diner isn't the type of place you just happen across due its location and so if you ever end up here it was because you actually planned on eating here. I ended up finding out about it through another Yelper and since it had good Yelp ratings and was somewhat close to my house I figured that I would give it a chance. The inside of the diner is quite interesting with a lunch counter on one side with all of the cooking done behind it. Then the other side has plastic booths (they remind me of my high school cafeteria) with some old photos on the wall.
For lunch on this day I decided to go with breakfast and so I ordered a 3 egg omelette with capicola, pepper jack cheese, onions and peppers with sides of hash browns and rye toast while my father went with a sausage and pepper sandwich with fries. My omelette came out at the same time as my dads sandwich (no fries though) and looked good. It was cooked nicely and I liked the flavor of the capicola in the omelette with the onions and peppers. While the cheese was pretty obvious in the omelette I don't think that I could have identified it as pepper jack as there wasn't any spice to it. By the time that I had finished my omelette my dads fries were still not there and so the waitress told us she would comp them but still deliver them whenever they were ready. Finally a minute or two later they were ready and came out to the table piping hot. Whenever it comes time to pay Dons diner is a little weird from the standpoint that I never saw a check. I just went up to the register and paid hoping that everything on the check was correct.
The bottom line for me is that I would head back here again in the future. I thought that my food was tasty and that it was good value for what we got. Be forewarned that Dons diner is cash only though!