Reading the other reviews made me laugh."Vapid skanks" - lmao. I am guessing he didn't score that night. This is a decent place. Food is ok (about what you would expect) and the different bar areas each have a different feel - sports bar to nightclub. Scatz books good bands - have never heard any that were bad - and the ages vary from 20 through real grown ups that actually have money. I do not feel out of place here, and neither do my 20 something daughters. I like the mix. Service can be inconsistent, not bad just distracted. There are more beautiful people at Scatz than any other place I know of in Madison that is not exclusively college kids. Maybe I am just into vapid skanks... This one of the larger clubs of its type in Madison. I have always had a good time at Scatz - good live music and a fun diverse crowd.
Update
My daughter suggests that if you like the music then you will probably like the crowd. If the music is not what you like, then you may not like the crowd. Makes sense.