I don't think there's a better seafood or steak place in the city.
If you're undecided on what to try, consider...
Any size fillet, oscar style
Chilean sea bass
Salt and pepper tuna
Diver scallops
Pair anything with the mac and cheese or mushrooms. Sides are meant to be shared
Start with tuna tartar or fondue, and end with the peanut butter pie
OP's wine list is very nice, but I think everyone should try a pinefin on the rocks at some point.