I like Matt's. I understand some of the criticisms but I also understand the raves.
Pros:
-The food IS good. Some of the items are breakfast basics, sure, but the pancakes are anything but ordinary. They're almost perfect. The home fries are great - rosemary goodness. There's also a great menu selection - a nice mix of breakfast standards with unique and special twists.
-The atmosphere. Yeah it's small, but it's part of the charm.
Con:
-It's expensive. There's no way around it.
- It IS small. You will have to wait, sometimes for a long time.