Mitchell's is a MUST stop for me when I'm in Cleveland. It doesn't matter which location! All of them have the friendliest staff; willing to give you a taste of anything that peaks your interest and very knowledgeable about ingredients!
I love to order the tasters duo; two smaller scoops of two flavors that total the size of about 1 regular scoop. It's always fun to mix and match. Some of my must try flavors include: vegan chocolate, coffee chocolate chunk, peppermint stick, pistachio, amaretto cookie, coconut, strawberry, wildberry crumble, and chocolate peanut butter pretzel.