I have been to Nazareth many times and the food is always amazing. My boyfriend and I always get the same thing - the vegetarian option with beef tibs. Beef is always tender and everything is seasoned perfectly.
A few things a first timer should know - this place is always busy and there is often a line. Wait in it - its worth it. The service is so-so but you will get what you've ordered and your drink will show up, eventually. The food is so good here that it makes up for wait time and service combined.
The prices are excellent and you will never leave hungry. Its quite the challenge to finish the entire plate.