I have been 3 times now and feel like I have a pretty good grasp of the place...and I love it. There is just something about the atmosphere that is very relaxed and welcoming and they always have great music playing.
I have eaten a different dish every time I've been and they have all been incredibly delicious. Their soup is made daily and always something interesting. As for their fries? I'm obsessed with them. They are quite possibly the best fries I've ever had.
The beer lineup is solid. They seem to have about 3 local or other craft brewery beers for every 1 beer they brew. That's ok though. The Street Cred American Dark Ale has quickly become my go to beer there and I think it could really stand as their flagship beer if they wanted.
The bartenders and servers have all been very friendly and knowledgeable about the food and beer. My service was A++ on 2 of my 3 visits. On the other occasion the service was less than desired and the food order was messed up. There was no reason for this as it wasn't busy. So my suggestion would be to write down the orders!
Can't wait for the next visit.