Came through here after an interview at their med school, I was looking for a fun looking place to be around some other students, and grab a bite to eat. This place was dark, depressing and had a bunch of old people in it. Why did I come in here? Some guy who had been to San Francisco was inside and called me in (we were walking around together, I prayed he wasn't going to rob me).
3 stars because the Guinness was well poured (and shamrocked), and the bratswurst was damn good.
Some younger people came in later, taking shots from plastic condiment cups-must be a Madison thing...