A group of us came here and couldn't figure out the menu (no, the waiters didn't bother to introduce the menu to us). But that was fine, because we decided to just have three red snappers to share between the nine of us, instead of ordering from the menu. We selected the three of the larger red snappers from the poissonerie and asked that they be grilled, with just olive oil and a touch of salt / pepper.
Boy it was worth the non-existent service.
The red snappers were fresh, succulent, and grilled to tasty perfection. It was singularly the most satisfying fish dinner I've had.
So fresh grilled fish: 5 stars.
Service: maybe 2.5 stars (but it appears that the servers were more attentive to some tables - probably those were regular clients).
Overall: I would still give 4 stars.