The food was good and reasonably priced. The fact that they offer a reasonably priced corkage option of $15 per bottle is a draw. The main issue here is with the service. We had great engagement from the server initially and then things began to fall apart. We selected The Hutch pizza which is chock full of spicy italian meats so having a glass of cold water would have been huge.
Also, we sat beside a window and had the window shade pulled down a bit. this was not due to the light but from the intense heat / greenhouse effect. Well, one of the wait staff decided that she was in charge and without asking, pulled the blinds right up. We viewed that as quite rude and someone with a bit of decency would have asked if that was ok. Bathrooms were small and one was out of order causing a queue.
I prefer the pizza crust at Pulcinella and Double 00 more and would probably choose one of those before revisiting Without Papers. That being said, it does have a ton of potential and if they are able to address their service issues, they will be in business for a long time.