My wife and I have been here a few times. We really liked our dinner from the previous time (sorry, no review), so we thought we'd give it try again. This time it was for the fish fry and beer.
We both ordered the same thing, the fried haddock with the salad bar. Comes with the choice of potato and salad bar. The salad bar was actually really good with a wide variety of toppings for your salad and, and, and warm delicious breadsticks.
Our server was fantastic. Brought me a sample of the featured $4 beer. It was pretty good but I decided to go with the pale ale. My wife had an old fashioned, which she said was good.
Overall, the breading on the fish was nice and crispy, light and honestly not too greasy. Coleslaw was the way I like it and the tartar sauce was fantastic, had a little fresh herb taste to it. The fries were good. Everything was good. Nice atmosphere. The place was packed (Badgers basketball was on too), but plenty of leg and arm room.
We'd definitely go back.