A group of friends and I went to Eat! Eat! today for the first time for breakfast. In my experience, the food was substandard for what you'd get a typical diner and in a small quantity, and on top of this the prices were expensive.
The poached eggs were done in an egg cooker and came with very few hash browns. It included a substantial amount of ham on the eggs benny, though. Although some may like that, I thought it was gross. The french toast had a thick coating of egg mixture on each side and was more reminiscent of sweet scrambled eggs stuck to the bread on each side.
I thought that the service was just fine despite the disappointing food.
Overall, in my opinion Eat! Eat! is a quaint little diner in a great location but I would not go back.