We were there for our monthly Smunch. Only about half the folks who said they were coming showed up. Their bad. Somehow the restaurant had started following Smunch on Twitter so they knew we were coming. They didn't know all the adults there were also Yelpers. I think the front of the house was over staffed for anything less than a full house, which it never came close to.
Never having been to another America's location I had nothing to compare it too. Two of our party are regulars at the 7th St and 7th Ave locations. All of us liked the food and the service. Fast casual is not a place I would normally tip but the service throughout was good enough all of us tipped on the way out. I had the taco trio and a Cochata. Very good stuff. If you go in and start moving tables around for a group they will actually bring out larger chip bowls and a large serving of each of the 3 dips for the table to share rather than the small serving with one salsa that normally comes with an entree. I am pretty sure we decided in order that the guacamole, then the spicier salsa then the mild salsa. In fact the mild hardly got touched.
So maybe it is only a 3-1/2 but it was so much better than the previous reviews had led us to believe that I rounded up instead of down this time.