Reading through these reviews makes me think that I may have been the only person to stumble upon the wonderful masterpiece that is NYPD's Baked Ziti.
Everyone listening? I'm reviewing their Baked Ziti NOT their pizza. It's the perfect combination of cheese, pasta and sauce. You get the rich flavor of their tomato sauce without being overwhelmed by it. The cheese is really the star of this dish and the sauce lets it shines.
The Pièce de résistance is the garlic knots that come on the side. Perfect addition to the best meal in the restaurant.
The reason why I say 4 out of 5 stars is because I can wait for quite a few minutes for are refill and to get the maximum enjoyment out of the meal I need to have my Diet Coke DURING the meal, not afterwords.