Went during my honeymoon and we went with the chef's tasting menu. It was a real treat. Beef cheek ravioli with a touch of 200 year old balsamic vinegar. The recommended preparation for everything was rare. Our server was extremely friendly and did a great job guiding us through the several courses of our meal.
If your budget is tight, you could share one order of the wine pairing to go along with the tasting menu. The pours are generous enough to share with each course.
My only regret was that we had show tickets for Jersey Boys immediately following and we got a little rushed. That was my error though in timing. Learn from my mistake and leave yourself plenty of time to enjoy.