First off we had the garlic knots. They were SO DAMN GOOD. Perfect balance of crispy outside with soft gooey insides and not overly garlic'd. The sauce was made fresh in house and had great flavor. We ordered 12 - 6 would be enough for most people as they are larger than I expected them to be. None survived though :)
Excellent pizza. Tried the margherita and was very impressed. The basil was super fresh, as were the tomatoes and it had clumps of gooey real mozzarella. The crust was perfect. If you like NY pizza this is the closest I've found it in AZ. The pepperoni was also very good. Not too greasy with nice flavor. Also, you can order by the slice and it still comes fresh so that was great for lunch.
For dessert the Snickers pie was amazing. It was not too sweet which is often something I dislike in those types of pie.
The owner, Vito, came over and chatted with us for a bit which was a nice touch and our server Nadine was super friendly and attentive. Dining room and restrooms were very clean. We will definitely be back to try other things off the menu. Hands down crushes Casanova Bros.