More like a 3.5 - it's decent, but not something I would wholeheartedly recommend.
I've been here twice. I can't explain it, but something seems off. I almost feel like I'm in one of those franchised stores. Except it's a crowd that's trying to not go to such a place.
Yeah - I'm being odd. I don't deny that.
As for the food - that's the 3.5. It's decent. The first time I had pizza - it was decent. My friend had the daily pasta (which I believe had lamb - that was actually really good), while my other friend's pizza was a bomb (flavorless). (much better pizzas include North of Brooklyn, Via Mercanti, and Mangia Bevi).
The second time I had salad. We also ordered a lot of appetizers. It literally lived up to being just "decent."
You won't go wrong, but I wouldn't necessarily say that you went right either.