See some yellow, and you're in the right place!
Got some keys cut here. Was super quick - in and out in literally minutes. I've since come back and cut three more keys and all have worked perfectly. And all of this for under 5$ per key... I've never had to do this before, but seems like a good price to me!
I poked around the store and it seems like they had a decent selection of all things hardware. I noted some real cool lightbulbs - might have to return for those. This could be a good one stop shop if you live nearby.